DEFEASANCE
FINANCEMENTS STRUCTURES
SOCIETES AD HOC -
SPECIAL PURPOSE VEHICLES TITRISATION
LES TECHNIQUES D'INGENIERIE JURIDIQUE
|
|
L'ingénierie juridique consiste à utiliser des
techniques juridiques pour faciliter en particulier ce que l'on appelle la
"gestion de bilan"
Il peut s'agir d'utiliser des techniques
contractuelles. Les techniques de "leasing" , de "location
financière" ou opérationnelle, permettent par exemple d'externaliser
des endettements et des charges financières, outre les avantages fiscaux
qu'elles peuvent éventuellement présenter.
Le développement des "garanties à
première demande" avait aussi pour avantage de ne pas inclure au titre des
cautions et garanties les engagements ainsi donnés.
Le développement de ce qui avait été appelé
le "Nouveau Capital", stimulé par la doctrine du "ni-ni"
s'est fait sur la base de montages que l'on peut qualifier d'ingénierie
juridique.
Il s'agit aussi de techniques de
gestion de
bilan, consistant à améliorer la structure de bilan ayant pour objet soit
d'individualiser un ensemble de risques (gestion du passif), soit un ensemble de
créances (gestion de l'actif). Il s'agit respectivement de la
defeasance
et de
la titrisation.
Ces techniques d'ingénierie juridique font
intervenir en particulier des notions de droit comptable, puisqu'il s'agit de
structure de bilan, la question étant de savoir si l'opération ne constitue
pas en fait un habillage de bilan pouvant être requalifié. Une analyse
rigoureuse doit être faite en tenant compte en particulier de l'impact
potentiel du droit du redressement judiciaire sur la séparation des éléments
d'actif.
L'ingénierie financière inclut aussi tout ce
qui se rattache aux "financements structurés"
Il est clair que l'efficacité de ces montages
dépend d'un degré de formalisme de la comptabilité, et que l'évolution vers
des règles comptables qui se fondent sur le risque et qui renverse le
"form over substance" remet en cause l'acrobatie de certains montages.
|
|
Bibliographie
Comptabilité et ingénierie juridico-financière,
Berlioz, Georges, Revue de droit comptable, n° 1, 01/01/1996,
pp 103-122
La titrisation
TITRISATION
Une technique de gestion
d’actif : la gestion active du bilan
La titrisation consiste à
transférer à des investisseurs les risques de crédit liés à un portefeuille
de créances non en les cédant.
Le recours par les entreprises aux opérations de titrisation et la désintermédiation
les classes d’actif titrisables par les entreprises (titrisations
« corporate ») : actifs corporels et créances
les créances commerciales : créances acquises et créances futures
clause de transfert de
recouvrementcccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
les opérations adossées à des stocks
l'amélioration des créances
Les montages
choix des véhicules de titrisation
la traduction comptable de l’opération de titrisation
Les FCC
Les FCC classiques
Les FCC à compartiments
loi 88-1201 du 23 décembre
1988? loi DDOEF du 2 juillet 1998
L’amélioration des créances
l’assurance
Xavier de Kergommeaux, Titrisation, le décret
nouveau est arrivé, Option Finance, 23/11/ 1998
La notation
La titrisation synthétique
La titrisation consiste à
transférer à des investisseurs les risques de crédit liés à un portefeuille
de créances non en les cédant, comme dans la titrisation classique, mais en
mettant en place des garanties de risques. La question principale est de savoir
si le risque a été effectivement transféré.
Articles
Eric Davoudet, Titrisation de
créances commerciales, une fiscalité en progrès ...relatif, Option Finance,
10/01/2000
CLO
Kissane, CormacKBC's synthetic CLO [collateralized
loan obligation] breathes life into Europe asset-backed market, International
Financial Law Review (IFLR), 01/08/2000,pp.
14-16
Titrisation en Chine
Peiji, Gao ; Kruger Paul, China faces
up to the new challenges of securization, The
Contract Law, International Financial Law Review (IFLR),n°
8, 01/08/2000,pp.
29-34
Titrisation en Suisse
Koch, Hans Andrée ; Giger, Marcel, Les
titrisations (asset-backed securities ou A.B.S), aspects juridiques et fiscaux,
Gaz. Pal. n° 196,
14/07/2000, p.19
La titrisation aux USA (securitization)
www.securitization.net
http://www.asset-backed.com/
Securitization
is a technique whereby assets are
pooled and security interests in the pool are sold. These operations are made
typically to institutional investors.
Assets
created in this manner include mortgage-backed securities wich are backed by
residential mortgages, and asset-backed securities which are backed by credit
card receivables or consumer installment loans.
In
a typical arrangement, the assets are transferred to a trust [ and security
interests are sold to investors. While various arrangements are used, typically,
principal and interest cash flows are paid directly to investors. In this way,
the investors incur the prepayment risk of the underlying assets.
Most
deals entail some sort of credit
enhancement. This may include over-collateralisation, a third party guarantee,
or other enhancements. For this reason, the securities tend to have excellent
credit ratings.
The
originator of the underlying assets may continue to process the assets—communicating
with borrowers and collecting their payments. They subtract a fee for doing so.
Alternatively, the originator may sell these "processing rights" to a
third party.
For
loan originators securitization is a means of removing risky assets from their
balance sheet, freeing up capital to support further loan writing.
For
investors, the securities offer yields that exceed those on comparable corporate
bonds. Because the deals are usually large and have high credit ratings, the
securities tend to be liquid—most are actively traded on secondary markets.
Mortgage-backed
security (MBS) is a bond which represents a securitized interest in
a pool of (typically residential) mortgages. The simplest form of MBS is a
mortgage pass-through. With that structure, all principal and interest payments
(less a processing fee) from the pool of mortgages are passed directly to
investors each month.
A
typical 30-year fixed-rate residential mortgage makes a fixed payment each month
until its maturity. Each payment represents a partial repayment of principal
along with interest on the outstanding principal. Over time, as more and more of
the principal is paid off, the size of the interest payment declines.
Accordingly, the proportion of each payment representing principal repayment
increases over the life of the mortgage.
Although
the scheduled payments on a mortgage are fixed from one month to the next, the
cash flows to the holder of a mortgage pass-through are not fixed. This is
because mortgage holders have the option of prepaying
their mortgages. When a mortgage holder exercises that option, their principal
prepayment is passed to the holder of the pass-through. This accelerates the
cash-flows to the holder of the pass-through who receives the principal payments
early, but never receives the future interest payments that would have been made
on that principal.
Prepayments
introduce uncertainty into the cash flows of a mortgage pass-through. The rate
at which mortgage holders prepay their mortgages is influenced by many factors,
not least of these being the level of interest rates. If interest rates decline
following the issuance of a mortgage, the mortgage holder is more likely to
prepay—refinancing the mortgage to take advantage of the lower rate. On the
other hand, if interest rates rise, the mortgage holder is more likely to not
prepay because the mortgage's rate is now low relative to rates otherwise
available in the market.
By
acting in their own best interest, mortgage holders act to the detriment of the
investor holding the mortgage pass-through. The duration of the pass-through
extends as interest rates rise, and contracts as interest rates fall. For this
reason, mortgage pass-throughs entail significant convexity risk. To compensate
investors for that convexity risk, pass-throughs typically offer higher yields
than comparable corporate bonds.
Despite
their market risk, mortgage pass-throughs typically entail little credit risk.
This is because they are usually insured by a US federal agency or quasi-federal
agency such as FHLMC (the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation, or "Freddie
Mac"), FNMA (the Federal National Mortgage Association, or "Fannie Mae")
or GNMA (the Government National Mortgage Association, or "Ginnie Mae")
Asset-backed
securities represent securitized interests in a pool of assets. Issues have been
backed by credit card receivables, auto loans and other forms of consumer
installment loans.
Investors
receive monthly payments of principal and interest. Securities backed by
installment loans operate much like a mortgage pass-through. All principal and interest payments flow directly to investors.
Securities
backed by revolving credit lines, such as credit cards, may delay distributing
principal during a lockout period. During that period, principal cash flows are
reinvested in additional receivables. Once the lockout period is over, principal
flows to the investors.
The
rate at which asset-backed securities pay down principal, as well as their
ultimate maturity date, is uncertain. This is because principal cash flows
depend upon the rate at which individual consumers decide to prepay their
indebtedness. However, because deals are large, and diversified across many
loans, this uncertainty is minimal. Unlike mortgage-backed securities, whose
prepayment rates are affected by changes in interest rates, asset-backed
security prepayments show little sensitivity to interest rates.
Articles
Coutenier, Brigitte, Les
techniques de mobilisation des créances internationales : aspects de droit
international et de droit comparé - Mechanisms of international
receivables-backed financing : aspects of international and comparative law,
Reveue de droit des affaires internationales- International Business, 01/03/1999
LA
SUBORDINATION
c.
Sekfali, Zine, La technique de la subordination dans les financements
d'acquistion d'entreprises, de projets et d'actis, régime juridique et pratique
en France, aux Etats Unis et en Grande Bretagne, Banque et Droit, 01/07/1999
titrisation en Afrique du Sud
http://www.sotta.co.za/
Russian equity market
http://www.rmg.ru/
securitization in Latin
America
http://www.standard-poors.com/ratings/criteria/structuredfinance/latin99.htm
|