6 Personal Injury Law Firms Compared: Practice Areas, Legal Services, and Case Results
Getting hurt in an accident is stressful enough without having to figure out which law firm deserves your trust. St. Louis has dozens of personal injury practices, and most of them promise aggressive representation and big results. That can make the decision harder, not easier. What actually separates one firm from another comes down to their track record, what types of cases they take on, how they treat clients, and whether they’re willing to go to trial.
If you’ve been searching for a car accident lawyer St. Louis residents trust after a collision, a structured comparison can save time and frustration. Below are six firms worth looking into, broken down by practice areas, legal services, and available case results.
1. TorHoerman Law
TorHoerman Law handles car accidents, truck crashes, catastrophic injuries, wrongful death, and mass tort litigation. The firm has been operating since 2009 and reports more than $4 billion recovered across its practice areas. That number reflects its full caseload, including product liability and chemical exposure work, so it speaks to the firm’s overall capacity rather than one category.
What makes TorHoerman worth comparing first is the level of detail on its car accident page. The firm publishes specific settlement amounts for motor vehicle claims. Examples of the firm’s published case results include a $1.5 million settlement in a fatal high-speed crash, a $498,700 settlement for a mother and daughter rear-ended on icy roads, and a $300,000 settlement for a passenger injured in a head-on collision caused by an intoxicated driver. Those published figures give prospective clients something concrete to evaluate.
The firm works on contingency and carries a 4.9-star Google rating from 256 reviews. It also has offices in St. Louis, Chicago, and Edwardsville.
2. Brown & Crouppen
Brown & Crouppen has been around since 1979. That kind of longevity says something. The firm handles auto accidents, truck wrecks, medical malpractice, workers’ compensation, and wrongful death. It reports more than $2 billion in total client recoveries and runs multiple offices across Missouri and surrounding states.
The scale here is the selling point. A larger team generally means more resources for investigating complex claims, consulting experts, and managing high-volume caseloads. Brown & Crouppen offers free consultations and contingency-fee representation.
One thing to consider: with a team this size, your day-to-day point of contact might be a paralegal or case manager rather than the lead attorney. That’s not necessarily bad, but it’s worth asking about before you sign.
3. OnderLaw
OnderLaw takes on car crashes, truck collisions, and a range of other injury cases. Its practice also extends into mass tort litigation, where groups of people bring claims tied to similar circumstances like defective products or toxic exposures.
The firm’s motor vehicle page reports over $7.5 billion in negotiated settlements, along with substantial trial verdicts. Those numbers cover its broader caseload and shouldn’t be read as car accident recoveries alone. OnderLaw advertises free case evaluations and a contingency-fee arrangement. It also reports more than 1,200 five-star reviews nationally.
OnderLaw could be a strong fit if your case involves serious injuries, disputed liability, or multiple parties who may share fault. Its mass tort background suggests comfort with complex, multi-party litigation.
4. Schultz & Myers
Schultz & Myers operates out of offices in St. Louis, Creve Coeur, Ladue, and Columbia. The firm focuses on personal injury work, including car accidents, motorcycle crashes, truck and bus accidents, bicycle and pedestrian accidents, dog bites, slip and fall injuries, and wrongful death.
The firm publishes individual case results on its website. Reported recoveries include a $2.3 million dram shop claim, a $1.75 million burn injury settlement, and an $850,000 result for a rear-end collision. Having those figures available makes it easier to assess what the firm has actually delivered for past clients.
Schultz & Myers carries roughly 1,000 Google reviews, which is a significant volume for a regional personal injury firm. The firm offers free consultations, and its multi-office footprint across the St. Louis metro area gives it a local presence that extends well beyond the city center.
5. Burger Law
Burger Law was founded by Gary Burger Jr. and operates from offices in St. Louis, Chicago, Chesterfield, and Belleville. The firm handles car accidents, workers’ compensation, product liability, medical malpractice, premises liability, and dog bite claims.
Two things stand out here. First, the review volume. Burger Law reports over 500 five-star Google reviews and more than 210 video testimonials from former clients. That’s an unusual level of documented client feedback for a mid-sized firm. Second, the firm’s case results have been featured in Missouri Lawyer’s Weekly, which adds third-party verification to its stated outcomes.
Burger Law also employs a former civil defense attorney, someone who previously represented the other side. That kind of perspective can be valuable when you’re dealing with an insurance company that’s pushing back on your claim.
6. Cofman Townsley
Cofman Townsley is based in Clayton, just outside St. Louis. The firm handles car accidents, truck collisions, traumatic brain injuries, wrongful death, dog bites, and workplace injuries. It reports over $1 billion in client recoveries and more than 40 years of combined legal experience.
What separates Cofman Townsley in this comparison is its trial record. Managing partner Todd Nissenholtz has secured multiple multi-million-dollar verdicts, including a $1.878 million result in a commercial vehicle crash case and a $1.705 million verdict in a motor vehicle crash where the defendant had offered just $100,000 before trial. He carries a Super Lawyer designation, and the firm holds an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell.
If your situation could end up in front of a jury, a firm with documented trial verdicts (not just settlements) gives you a different kind of leverage during negotiations.
What Should You Ask Before Choosing a Firm?
Comparing published recovery amounts and review scores is a reasonable place to start. But those numbers only tell part of the story. Before signing a retainer, ask a few pointed questions. Find out who will actually work on your case. Some firms assign a lead attorney from day one. Others route communication through support staff. Neither is wrong, but you should know what to expect.
Ask about experience with cases like yours. A firm that’s recovered billions across mass tort litigation may not be the best fit for a straightforward rear-end collision, and vice versa. Relevant experience matters more than total dollar figures. Get clear answers on fees. Most personal injury firms work on contingency, meaning you don’t pay unless they win. Still, ask about case expenses, deductions, and what happens if the claim doesn’t succeed.
Check recent reviews across more than one platform. Patterns in client feedback, especially around communication and follow-through, reveal more than a star rating ever will. A consultation is the most direct way to evaluate whether a firm is a good match. Use it to ask specific questions about your accident and pay attention to how the attorney responds. The right firm won’t just list credentials. It will listen to your situation and explain, plainly, how it plans to help.
